These are by no means exhaustive lists, but worrying trends are occurring where people set up as a dog professional and harm occurs to the dog and the relationship between the dog and their guardian.
It is really important to know who you are working with/ hiring. Our dogs are our family members and it's important that we check out who we are hiring just like we would a child minder! Image description: A two pane comic strip with a grey background. The title reads: Navigating the waters of hiring a dog behaviourist: spotting warning signs and good omens The first top window is of a Wolfdog pulling a red banner (symbolising a red flag), in a play bow position. The red banner reads in bullet point style: Offers guarantees no qualifications/ won’t share certifications No force/fear free or ethical memberships no follow ups doesn’t want to observe the behaviour doesnt work across a multidisciplinary team one known protocol fits all blames breed and or guardian uses or resorts to use of aversion/ punishment/flooding zero Professional experience under a mentor no consultation pack has no clue why behaviour occurs The bottom window is of a Wolfdog pulling a green banner (symbolising a green flag), in a play bow position. The green banner reads in bullet point style: Does not offer guarantees - Explains why not ethical shares certifications - encourages to check testimonials Fear & force free & ethical memberships/ accreditation Follows up/ maintains regular contact Wants to observe the behaviour as naturally occurs Works across a multidisciplinary team Tailored behaviour modification plan based on consultation pack and sets timely reviews Uses only fear, force free methods or holistic Professional experience under a mentor for years consultation pack Happy to refer on if not a great symbiosis doesn’t blame guardian or breed
0 Comments
Prey drive blog part three
YouTube audio link: 5 minutes 45 seconds duration. https://youtu.be/yo2MTKJevwU?si=Kh2thabD4VmEaSWb “We are all geniuses but if you judge a fish to climb a tree, it will live its whole life believing it is stupid.” Prey drive is a fundamental behaviour for many breeds of dogs, prey drive is a simple behavioural pattern of chasing and capturing prey. Humans have selected bred dogs to still be able to hunt with the human and for the human needs but breeding out of the prey drive behaviours. (1) There are many herding and hunting breeds who share a couch with you. Do you know and understand the heritability and genetic traits of your dog? In other words, do you know what your dog was originally bred for? Historically. Not the line from the breeder but the original reason? It's surprising how many people aren't aware. I want to raise awareness that the dog we share our couch with is in fact a predator, a skilled hunter and has phenomenal scent detection skills. Understanding and nodding to our dogs history and the original reason for their breeding is a sign of respect and understanding of their biological needs. Do we need to correct a behaviour or make the dog cut it out or curb the behaviour? (Shudder). No, absolutely not. We need to say: “Hey, I share my home with a predator. I may also share my home with a cat (another predator), a hedgehog (another predator), a reptile (another predator), a rabbit (prey), a mouse (prey)... It's really important that we understand the species of the animal we share our home with. We need to understand and appreciate their behaviour. Humans get away with lots of behaviours others may find annoying, irritating, anxiety inducing or just plain unpleasant. People are not biologically programmed to be unkind or hurtful yet many are. We cannot compare an animal to a human and apply human ideologies and expectations onto a dog or any animal we share our home with. This very much brings Albert Einstein’s quote to mind: “We are all geniuses but if you judge a fish to climb a tree, it will live its whole life believing it is stupid.” Ergo if we deny our dogs their species and biological needs, you're going to have one very frustrated and possibly ill dog (as illness in dogs can and is caused by stress) and one strung out and frustrated human. Think of it this way. As much as we try to, we as professionals just cannot convince the general public dogs are not related to wolves. The scientist who said this even back tracked himself, very publicly. Our dogs however are still predators in their own right, look at the toys we are offered. Squeaky toy. (Prey). Tug. (Prey). Giggly balls. (Prey). Kongs, Kong wobbles, giros… All prey. Soda pup, again prey. Because even enrichment meets a sequence of the prey drive sequence of the dissect and consume process. We buy toys to meet our dogs needs, even if you do dog sports you are still illociting the behaviour for the reward at the end in many cases is a ball, a tug, something to grab and bite and depending on your style, dissect and kill. In normal food reward based training, the dog does a behaviour and possibly a behaviour sequence and is rewarded with food! There are so many ways to work with prey drive without any aversive or compulsion based tools or unkind methods. When your dog chases birds, rabbits, squirrels this causes them to have a dopamine rush and it doesn't matter what you say that high is euphoric and causes extreme enjoyment. Just as humans also experience. You wouldn't want to be interrupted during a high and euphoric moment either. If your dog has no recall or you worry they will chase, use a long line, you have the freedom of the radius of the long line but ultimately your dog is safe and you are both going home without vet bills, a dog warden visit or worse. We have lots of games and tutorials on our YouTube channel https://youtu.be/En1SGEfcmuw?si=2WGH58TJdciFYV53 you can use these resources to learn from and to train your dog. They have text to speech to help viewers and you can visit them as many times as you like. References Siniscalchi M, Bertino D, d'Ingeo S, Quaranta A. Relationship between motor laterality and aggressive behavior in sheepdogs. Symmetry. (2019) 11:233. doi: 10.3390/sym11020233 Image description Image description: A three window comic panel which is grey. The title reads: prey drive and livestock force and fear free solutions. The first window is of a Wolfdog chasing sheep on a country hillside. With a blue and yellow sky. The text box reads: You don't need an e collar to stop this behaviour, but a little bit of common sense and a responsibility. The second window is of a wolfdog running in a secure dog field. With a blue sky background. There is a fence and tufts of grass growing by the fence. The text box reads: utilise enclosed dog fields, long lines and check fields for livestock. Avoid fields with livestock. The third bottom window is of a Wheelchair user with blonde, pink, purple ombre hair sat in a Wheelchair with a Wolfdog either side engaging with a backdrop of a sheep herd on fields with a blue sky in the distance. The text box reads: working on predation substitute training and work on stimuli which triggers a prey chase behaviour. Audio link: Youtube: duration 13 mins 11 secs https://youtu.be/ltwmdaKLhPk?si=Vthk-ic74kxVRGHC In the previous prey drive blog I explored the role of genetics, epigenetics and genome mapping in understanding the predation behaviours of dogs. It is important to acknowledge genetic influences on dog behaviour as dogs are evolving all of the time. With each litter the genes from their parents do influence behaviour. DNA is altered by the methylation, which affects gene expression in future generations depending on the behaviours of the mother. (1) It is also equally important to also respect that the environment, learning through life and the opportunity to rehearse behaviours, especially successfully contributes to how much a dog's behaviour is influenced. (2) Early experiences for a dog will dramatically affect their behaviour throughout their life, researchers have found that if a dog was to be ill as a puppy, the guardians would experience more unwanted behaviours than that of a guardian with a dog who didn't experience illness or unwellness as a young dog. (3) The documented behaviours found were fear related behaviours and “aggressive” behaviours towards strangers, separation anxiety, barking and humping. As a personal note, I know of many dogs who experienced illness during early life such as giardia, parvo and bone problems which inhibited these dogs as puppies from early life experiences, some dogs were absolutely fine and some dogs needed support. So I would just like to reassure anyone fearful of having an unwell puppy. This does not mean that you will absolutely have behavioural problems as your puppy grows into adulthood. With any academia we have to remember that many sample groups for statistics are very small and data is not always accurately given. A poor diet and a lack of nutrients in a puppies life can also alter their behaviour as they grow, a dog's brain development is reliant upon polyunsaturated fatty acids. As the brain needs these nutrients for cognition and learning. (4) If you would like to learn more about diet and nutrition you can refer back to my previous blog on diet to learn more. Look at this post on Facebook https://www.facebook.com/share/iUgafRQKsnVv6J9u/?mibextid=WC7FNe Phenotyping a dog is a delicate balance to include validity, sensitivity and to be as objective as possible. In medicine diseases are easy to identify as there will be specific components to look for to diagnose. However there is no such thing to identify behavioural traits, which makes diagnosis more complex and restrictive. Which means researchers rely on questionnaires from dog guardians to gather data, but we always have to be mindful that what the guardian interprets may not be accurate if there is limited knowledge as to the dogs behaviour and motivations. Just as we as behaviourists would not understand the coding of blood tests for example whereas trained and experienced medical staff do know this. We are all experts within our own forums and professions and this does not mean that anyone is lacking in knowledge, skills or intelligence, we are simply on different paths of study. There are many tests that have been met with scepticism due to human error and bias when interpreting behaviours of a specific breed. Especially if a particular breed is a favourite of the tester. This was shown by Diederich and Giffroy (5), they found in their research that there was a lack of standardisation widespread within the parameters. These parameters included indoor and outdoor dogs, age ranges, social and environmental stimuli used. For example when looking at sound sensitivities there were far too many variables from an alarm clock to a siren. They also found a lack of standardisation in canine laterality tests. (6) Laterality simply means the preferred side the dog has for example being right handed or left handed. Many of my conditioning and Trick clients know that I always say that every individual dog has a preference to which they will prefer to lie on to roll or step forward with to interact with a piece of conditioning equipment. Some tests only looked at one behavioural trait to understand such as the Ainsworth strange test which specifically looked at dog and guardian attachment using a series of controlled tests and a controlled environment. (7) As mentioned above results can also be influenced by external influences, such as judges. Another test is the mentality test, used to test thousands of Swedish dogs annually. These results would be compared with the answers from the guardians completed questionnaire. Ruefenacht ( identified the heritability of traits within German Shepherds such as hardness, defence drive and confidence which is influenced by the age and sex of the dog, the breeding and the judge. (9) Whereas when looking at livestock guardian breeds, objectivity in selection for herding breeds and successful breeding programmes for the complexity of traits of the livestock guardian dog. (10) But again it is important to be mindful that many testing areas are unfamiliar to the dog and the dog may not feel safe or the dog maybe too engaged with the new environment. This is where guardian questionnaires are valuable as nobody knows their dog better than their guardian. The dog is also in their own home which again many who work with me know how much I value this environment and not a strange environment to travel to. There are two types of main questionnaires which guardians have been asked to participate with for reliable data. The Canine Behavioural Assessment and Research Questionnaire also known as C-BARQ which has been used by many researchers for data. There is also the Monash Canine Personality Questionnaire - Revised (MCPQ-R). (11,12) The other problem which has been identified is the use of terminology and the understanding of the behaviour. It has been found that too many behaviours were being grouped together instead of being identified as their stand alone sub-type. For example aggression, resource guarding, defensiveness, fear and anxiety. There was too much divergence between the emotional state and motivation of the dog as perceived by the testers, which meant as a stand alone diagnostic tool the results would be inaccurate. This included 15 international Veterinary behaviourists. Which shows due to human error just how a dog's behaviour and emotions can be interpreted in different ways by using different language to identify essentially the same diagnosis of behaviour or emotion. (13,14) It may seem strange that I am breaking down and explaining genetics and phenotyping in depth to simply share how to work with your dog with prey drive and predation behaviours. But as said before in the previous blog, in order to truly understand your dog as an individual we first need to understand all of the components that brings about this behaviour for you both to be successful in your learning journey! References Champagne FA, Curley JP: Epigenetic mechanisms mediating the long-term effects of maternal care on development. Neurosci Biobehav Rev2009,33(4):593–600. 10.1016/j.neubiorev.2007.10.009 Scott JP, Fuller JL: Genetics and the social behaviour of the Dog. Chicago: The University of Chicago Press; 1965. Serpell J, Jagoe JA: Early experience and the development of behaviour. In The Domestic Dog: Its evolution, behaviour and interactions with people. Edited by: Serpell J. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press; 1995:79–102. Overall KL: That dog is smarter than you know: advances in understanding canine learning, memory, and cognition. Top Companion Anim Med2011,26(1):2–9. 10.1053/j.tcam.2011.01.001 Diederich C, Giffroy J: Behavioural testing in dogs: a review of methodology in search for standardisation☆. App Anim Behav Sci2006,97(1):51–72. 10.1016/j.applanim.2005.11.018 Tomkins LM, McGreevy PD, Branson NJ: Lack of standardization in reporting motor laterality in the domestic dog (Canis familiaris). J Vet Behav:Clin Appl Res 2010,5(5):235–239. 10.1016/j.jveb.2010.03.002 Topál, J., Miklósi Csányi, V., and Dóka, A. (1998). Attachment behavior in dogs (Canis familiaris): a new application of Ainsworth’s (1969) strange situation test. J. Comp. Psychol.112, 219–229. doi: 10.1037//0735-7036.112.3.219 Ruefenacht S, Gebhardt-Henrich S, Miyake T, Gaillard C: A behaviour test on German Shepherd dogs: heritability of seven different traits. App Anim Behav Sci 2002,79(2):113–132. 10.1016/S0168-1591(02)00134-X Thomson PC, Wilson BJ, Wade CM, Shariflou MR, James JW, Tammen I, Raadsma HW, Nicholas FW: The utility of estimated breeding values for inherited disorders of dogs. Vet J 2010,183(3):243–244. 10.1016/j.tvjl.2009.12.002 Arvelius P, Malm S, Svartberg K, Strandberg E: Measuring herding behavior in Border collie-effect of protocol structure on usefulness for selection. J Vet Behav:Clin Appl Res 2013,8(1):9–18. 10.1016/j.jveb.2012.04.007 Hsu Y, Serpell JA: Development and validation of a questionnaire for measuring behavior and temperament traits in pet dogs. J Am Vet Med Assoc2003,223(9):1293–1300. 10.2460/javma.2003.223.1293 Duffy D, Serpell J: Behavioral assessment of guide and service dogs. J Vet Behav:Clin Appl Res 2008,3(4):186–188. Overall KL, Crowell-Davis SL, Dehasse J, Fatjó J, Houpt KA, Mills DS, Palestrini C, Beata C, Seksel K: Terminology think tank. J Vet Behav:Clin Appl Res 2006,1(1, 2, 3):29–46. 80–83, 121–123 Ohl F, Arndt SS, van der Staay FJ: Pathological anxiety in animals. Vet J2008,175(1):18–26. 10.1016/j.tvjl.2006.12.013 Image description: A three window comic panel which is grey. The title reads: prey drive and livestock force and fear free solutions. The first window is of a Wolfdog chasing sheep on a country hillside. With a blue and yellow sky. The text box reads: You don't need an e collar to stop this behaviour, but a little bit of common sense and a responsibility. The second window is of a wolfdog running in a secure dog field. With a blue sky background. There is a fence and tufts of grass growing by the fence. The text box reads: utilise enclosed dog fields, long lines and check fields for livestock. Avoid fields with livestock. The third bottom window is of a Wheelchair user with blonde, pink, purple ombre hair sat in a Wheelchair with a Wolfdog either side engaging with a backdrop of a sheep herd on fields with a blue sky in the distance. The text box reads: working on predation substitute training and work on stimuli which triggers a prey chase behaviour. Audio link: 8 minutes 20 seconds https://youtu.be/DphYB55XIwI?si=d9c7HsbtfpCm6tf7 In this blog we will be exploring predation and prey drive behaviour in dogs. Many guardians struggle with their dogs chasing cats, squirrels, livestock, other dogs and other species such as deers, birds and smaller wild animals. Many guardians believe that this behaviour is due to the dog's genetics and they aren't wrong. This will be a blog series. It is really important that we understand breed, genetic and phenotyping before exploring prey drive behaviour in dogs so that we have a full understanding of how to help our individual dog. Dogs became an important part of life during the 19th century, artificial selection began and extensive records of dogs lineage were recorded. Breed standards were introduced, stud books were produced and the purpose of the breeding for the dog such as herding was also documented. (1) During this time dogs entered into another transition of being selectively bred for working roles to being artificially selected for fashion reasons. The dogs that we have today in the modern world face even more challenges within a modern household and society setting. Due to the possible frustration of not being able to express breed related behaviours, they can also become frustrated due to the isolation, non stimulating environments and frustration of inactivity. Due to this the dog is evolving all of the time, with dog's being artificially selected to fit in with the ever changing demands of what people desire from a dog within a modern world. The companion dog today can still be viewed or acknowledged as an evolutionary work in progress. (2) The way in which dogs have been artificially selected the genome for dogs is able to be studied clearly, scientists have found small and large variations between the genomes of breeds. (3) From the learning and the research behind the genetics and the genomic maps of dogs, researchers spend a lot of time investing into the learning of breed specific behavioural traits. Researchers have also found mapping genes frustrating due to the complexity of the mapping. Researchers are now looking at phenotyping to see if this can be more successful in fully understanding the genes of dogs. (4) (5) Phenotyping comes from the Greek phainen, which means to show and tupos which means type. This word means the characteristics of an organism and the observable traits, resulting from the genotype interactions with the environment. So phenotypes best reflect nature and nurture. (6) Due to the complexity of dog behaviour we cannot rely on genetics and breed traits alone. Epigenetics also play a role within an individual dog's behaviour. Epigenetics are the addition of changes to gene expression. Epigenetics take place before the puppies are born, whilst they are growing inside their mother. Epigenetics can also be added due to the mothers nutrition during her pregnancy and if she has any fearful experiences during pregnancy such as fireworks, separation anxiety or a traumatic event. Epigenetics change all the time through different periods of growth, they can be removed or added to through the environment, behaviours, the environment and poor health such as infections and cancer. (7) Epigenetics and genes can and do change all of the time. So even though good breeders will select a mother and father for desired traits, such as behaviour, coat type, health and development, the puppy is being influenced all of the time from gestation to birth and throughout all of their life. It may seem odd that I am writing about predatory behaviour, however in order to understand your individual dog and their behaviour we have to understand your dog as a species and how their behaviour can be influenced by their breed type, genes, phenotype, life experiences and poor health episodes. Many people stereotypically think of a dog breed such as a border collie and automatically make the association of herding. Because this is what they were bred to do. Many dogs have been purpose bred for working and we all make typical associations of the breed and what we expect them to do based on that breed, another example Labrador retriever, retrieving. Guardians can become frustrated with intense genetic behaviours, such as herding, retrieving, aloof behaviour and more. Guardians can also become frustrated if their dog does not seem to concede to the behaviour of their breed and the expected behaviour of the breed. For example a German Shepherd that doesn't alert bark or a livestock guardian dog breed who doesn't want to guard. It is really important that we understand breed, genetic and phenotyping before exploring prey drive behaviour in dogs so that we have a full understanding of how to help our individual dog. So in coming back to the introduction we need to help them to feel safe and secure in our relationship, communications and learning. References McGreevy PD, Bennett P: Challenges and paradoxes in the companion animal niche. Anim Welf 2010,19(S):11–16. McGreevy PD, Bennett P: Challenges and paradoxes in the companion animal niche. Anim Welf 2010,19(S):11–16. Lindblad-Toh K, Wade CM, Mikkelsen TS, Karlsson EK, Jaffe DB, Kamal M, Clamp M, Chang JL, Kulbokas EJ 3rd, Zody MC, Mauceli E, Xie X, Breen M, Wayne RK, Ostrander EA, Ponting CP, Galibert F, Smith DR, DeJong PJ, Kirkness E, Alvarez P, Biagi T, Brockman W, Butler J, Chin CW, Cook A, Cuff J, Daly MJ, DeCaprio D, Gnerre S, et al.: Genome sequence, comparative analysis and haplotype structure of the domestic dog. Nature 2005,438(7069):803–819. 10.1038/nature04338 Hall NJ, Wynne CD: The canid genome: behavioral geneticists’ best friend?Genes Brain Behav 2012, 11: 889–902. Hall NJ, Wynne CD: The canid genome: behavioral geneticists’ best friend?Genes Brain Behav 2012, 11: 889–902. Wanscher 1975; Mayr 1982; Henig 2001, Jewell 2001 Heijmans B, Tobi E, Stein A, et al., Persistent epigenetic differences associated with prenatal exposure to famine in humans. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 2008; 105: 17046-17049. Image description: A three window comic panel which is grey. The title reads: prey drive and livestock force and fear free solutions. The first window is of a Wolfdog chasing sheep on a country hillside. With a blue and yellow sky. The text box reads: You don't need an e collar to stop this behaviour, but a little bit of common sense and a responsibility. The second window is of a wolfdog running in a secure dog field. With a blue sky background. There is a fence and tufts of grass growing by the fence. The text box reads: utilise enclosed dog fields, long lines and check fields for livestock. Avoid fields with livestock. The third bottom window is of a Wheelchair user with blonde, pink, purple ombre hair sat in a Wheelchair with a Wolfdog either side engaging with a backdrop of a sheep herd on fields with a blue sky in the distance. The text box reads: working on predation substitute training and work on stimuli which triggers a prey chase behaviour. Happy New Year and let's kick off 2024 with a Wicked Wednesday. I thought about being more sassy but toned it down. Don't want to upset too many on a new year return.
Image description: Albert Einstein - an older gentleman with white hair, sticking out his tongue at the camera. In a black and white photo. The top of the image has a blue text box with the text reads: protons and neutrons, stick together just like a dog with a fear opposed professional. The bottom text box which is also blue with black text reads: electrons angrily circle outside of them just like aversive trainers. |
BlogFor Mutts & Mischief If you enjoy my blogs and
would like to support my work, you can support me by buying me a Coffee! Archives
July 2024
|